Land of Confusion Analysis

Yet again, I must apologize for the length of time between posts; my computer has been locking up randomly for the last couple of weeks and I have finally tracked down this issue to a faulty video card. Now that the problem has been resolved, I bring you the second installment of my new video analysis series.

Last time, for those who have not read it, I examined “If Anyone Gets Funked Up (It’s Gonna Be You)” by George Clinton. This time, I will actually be critiquing two videos and comparing and contrasting them: “Land of Confusion” by Genesis and Disturbed’s “Land of Confusion”. The adage states that one should never ascribe to malice what can adequately be ascribed to incompetence; from the two videos it appears that Genesis assumes that our world is ran by incompetents while Disturbed believes that our rulers are malicious.

Incidences of incompetence are many in the Genesis incarnation and most of them involve Ronald Reagan; in fairness this is probably due to the fact that most of the focus of the video revolves around Reagan and is probably not a commentary on his presidency. The first incident – which is repeated several times in the video – is Reagan mistaking an Ape for Nancy. Near the end, when he attempts to take a drink of water, he splashes it behind him without any of it reaching his mouth – fortunately Nancy is wearing a snorkel in preparation. And possibly the most egregious incident is when Reagan carelessly pushes the missile launch button instead of the nurse button.

Disturbed’s version of this video is much darker with a mysterious cowled figure leading an uprising of citizens against rulers bent on subjugating and killing their subjects. World leaders assemble under a flag emblazoned with the dollar sign. These leaders send forth soldiers to march on cities wearing similar emblems on their sleeves; to make it clear that Disturbed is not singling out any particular country as the source of corruption, but rather all governments – flags of Japan, France, Great Britain, the United States, and Russia supplant the dollar insignia on the marching soldiers’ sleeves.

The cowled figure of the Disturbed video – who could be any of us as his face is never shown – indicates that in fact it is ordinary citizens who must make the world better; during the line “Superman, where are you now” a paper with the letter “S” blows onto his chest and is promptly ripped away letting the viewer know that this man is nothing special. The Genesis video on the other hand, shows an incompetent leader attempting to play Superman without much success. This in its own way suggests that we shouldn’t look to our political leaders to fix all of the world’s problems for us.

In many ways, both videos have the same messages: governments should not be trusted, ordinary citizens should fix the problems in the world and not expect leaders to do so, and the fate of society is being dictated by people who are not up to this task. Disturbed’s world view is much more bleak than Genesis’s commentary however; Genesis appears to think that leaders are doing their best, but that they do not have much skill or intellect while Disturbed appears to believe that governments are ruled by insane, power-mad, war-mongers.

In truth, I am sure that some governments are led by idiots while others are ruled by merciless tyrants, but – call me naive – I would like to think that most governments are made up of ordinary people doing their best but can only do so much. In this scenario, the masses still have to work at making the world better as they are just that – the masses. If a few honest leaders are working to improve the world, and everyone else is standing aside watching, nothing will ever get accomplished.

24 Comments

  1. MadMadMargo says:

    Excellent post! I enjoyed reading this review.

  2. Rajaat99 says:

    Wonderful analysis.
    I disagree, however. I believe that our (The United States) government is run by both incompetent people and merciless tyrants.

  3. cball says:

    Fair enough. Well, at least if they are going to be tyrants, I would prefer them to be idiots as their plans of world domination may not succeed. 🙂

  4. s5011502 says:

    awesome post, helped a lot as an example
    analysis for my school assignment.
    Thanks

  5. cball says:

    Thanks for the comment. I am always glad to help someone out.

  6. Pierre-Andr says:

    Being always in research of improving my musical culture in every possible way, I love finding sites and analyses like these!
    And your view about those two videos is, according to my humble knowledge, very accurate and interesting. Both clips leave us discomfortable, but indeed in a different way. And behind Disturbed’s apparently simplier ideas, lies a real message that should make us rethink some of our own views.
    I hope reading you again sooner or later 🙂

  7. Very good blog! Do you have any helpful hints for aspiring
    writers? I’m hoping to start my own website soon but I’m a little lost on everything.
    Would you advise starting with a free platform like
    Wordpress or go for a paid option? There are so many choices out there that I’m totally confused ..
    Any ideas? Thank you!

  8. Agen judi bola judi online – http://www.stockmarketfunding.com, bursa taruhan bola m8win.

  9. http://Id.fm-p.jp

    Music Discussions » Blog Archive » Land of Confusion Analysis…

  10. Kay says:

    When performing an “open rhinoplasty”, an incision is created
    in the location of skin separating the nostrils.

  11. website says:

    Hello to every one, it’s genuinely a good for me to pay a quick
    visit this website, it consists of important Information.

  12. Welcome back to a different weblog post from
    yours definitely.

  13. they said says:

    they said…

    blog topic…

  14. What Is A Benchmark Loan Payment?…

    blog topic…

  15. ello.co says:

    ello.co…

    blog topic…

  16. I don’t know whether it’s just me or iff perhaps everybody else encountering problems with your site.
    It seems like some of the text on your content are
    running off the screen. Caan someone else please provide
    feedback and let me know if this is happening to them as well?
    This might be a problem with my web browser because I’ve
    had this happen previously. Cheers

    Here iis my webpage; Public Services for communities; opseuregion4.Org,

  17. Excellent post. Keep posting such kind of information on your blog.
    Im really impressed bby your site.
    Hi there, You’ve done a great job. I’ll definitely dkgg iit and personally recommend to my friends.

    I am confident they will be benefited from this site.

    Here iss my webbsite – fixer upper houses (Nwgreatfalls.org)

  18. Very quickly this site willl be famous among all blog viewers, due to it’s pleasant content

    Also visit my blo post :: bike tour (cicloturistalasgrullas.com)

  19. I’ve been browsing onliune greater thhan 3 hours nowadays, yet I
    by no means discovered anny fascinating article like yours.

    It’s beautiful price sufficient for me. Personally, iif all website owners and bloggers made excellent content as yoou did, the internet can bbe much more helpful than everr before.

    My web-site Double Exposjre Radio (Doublexposureradio.com)

  20. Online casinos induce suit progressively pop in Recent years, and the Joined Kingdom is no elision. With a flourishing total of online casinos in the UK, players right away sustain Thomas More options than e’er in front.

    Peerless of the Francis Scott Key benefits of online casinos is comfort station. Players terminate enjoy their darling cassino games from the comfortableness of their have home, without having to journey to a forcible casino. This makes online casinos an nonpareil select for players who dwell Army for the Liberation of Rwanda aside from a gambling casino or who don’t get the time to impose nonpareil.

    Another profit of online casinos is the blanket miscellany of games on offering. Online casinos tender everything from classic hold over games wish jack oak and line roulette to the in vogue television slots and imperfect jackpots. This way that players put up well recover games that accommodate their tastes and preferences.

    In addition, many online casinos put up bonuses and promotions to draw in New players and go on existent ones approaching dorsum. These bathroom let in receive bonuses, disengage spins, and loyalty rewards. Players should always take the footing and conditions of these offers to take a shit certainly they infer the wagering requirements and whatever other restrictions.

    When choosing an online casino, players should e’er create sure that the site is accredited by the UK Gaming Commission. This ensures that the cassino is operational lawfully and that players are saved. Players should as well expect for casinos that habituate reputable software package providers to guarantee that the games are average and random.

    Overall, online casinos make get a pop prize for players in the UK. With their convenience, wide-cut reach of games, and attractive bonuses, they bid a eager alternative to traditional brick-and-howitzer casinos. As tenacious as players select a commissioned and reputable casino, they arse enjoy a safe and pleasurable play get from the ease of their own home base.

Leave a Reply